Should the FIFA 2022 World Cup be held in Qatar?

In 2022, Qatar will become the first Arab nation to host the FIFA World Cup, albeit it under widespread corruption allegations. After hosting a successful Asian Games in 2006, FIFA believe that the Arabic regions deserve the opportunity to host such a prestigious event. As the World’s richest country prepare themselves for a world cup so steeped in controversy, we look at the ethical implications of hosting a global event under such media scrutiny.

Why should Qatar host the world cup?

As previously mentioned, Qatar will become the first country in the Middle East to host the FIFA World Cup. Hosting such a prestigious tournament would provide a huge contribution to increasing tourism to both Qatar and its neighbouring countries. Spectators from around the world will come to be part of this huge event and visit a country they most likely never thought of visiting before. Furthermore, the FIFA World Cup is a hugely televised event watched by over 3 billion viewers, thus providing an international platform for Qatar to showcase their country.

With the publicity that Qatar will get during the World Cup, Qatar’s aim to become the ‘next Dubai’ will become more attainable. The majority of the perimeter of Qatar is surrounded by the Arabian Gulf, therefore providing a great destination for sun and beach getaways, which can be publicised during the World Cup. As well as this, the stunning, modern Qatari architecture is an attraction in itself – and a growing one at that!

With plans to become the ‘next Dubai’ in terms of tourism, Qatar will have to accelerate the development of the country – using its small size as an asset by efficiently linking cities together. With stadiums being the central hub to many redevelopment projects in Qatar, including one situated in the centre of a city that hasn’t been built yet, the growth of Qatar is an exciting expansion, especially from an engineer’s perspective.

However, such development comes with huge expenses. With Qatar needing to build many stadiums and hotels to accommodate the tournament, a lot of money must be invested into the 2022 FIFA World Cup. As mentioned, Qatar has been named to be the richest country in the world. With this wealth, Qatar are willing to invest a lot of money to create some remarkable architecture which perhaps the other world cup 2022 candidates would not be able to fund. By investing so much money into innovative architectural designs, the stadiums for the 2022 World Cup could be the next landmarks for Qatar that could go down in engineering history, similar to the Sydney Opera House in Australia.

PRE Image 1With 3 current stadiums to be expanded and 9 new stadiums to be built, a vast amount of construction work is to take place in Qatar in the coming years. This means that around 1.5 million jobs will be created, most of which are in construction, engineering and machinery operation. As Qatar has a population of only 2.7million, many of the workers are Indian and Nepalese migrants, strengthening links with nearby countries.

But why the controversy?

Recently, the corruption scandal involving FIFA and its president Sepp Blatter has been very much in the public eye. Rumour of bribery is rife and a criminal investigation is currently ongoing into the behaviour of Blatter. It is clear that the decision that Qatar is to host the 2022 World Cup has not been based solely upon what is best for football or Qatar itself and has been influenced by a number of exterior, immoral factors. The chance to host a World Cup is a proud moment for any nation but this opportunity has been tarnished by greed and corruption.

One of the most controversial issues since Qatar was awarded the World Cup have been the countries attitude to the human rights of the immigrant workforce being used as labourers. Investigations have found evidence to suggest that these workers face exploitation and abuses that amount to modern day slavery. Under the current system employers take hold of the worker’s passport and can bar them from changing job without permission. Further to this it has been reported that over 1,200 workers have died already working on this project.

PRE Image 2.jpgHistorically the tournament has been a summer event, some may question the decision to therefore award it to a country with 40-50C heat in the summer months. To combat this issue FIFA have taken the unprecedented step of moving the tournament to winter. This will have a profound effect on football not only in Qatar but throughout the world. As aforementioned, the link between awarding the tournament to Qatar and the current corruption scandal with FIFA is unequivocal. Should a tournament in Qatar, with a bid shrouded in controversy, be allowed disrupt such long standing European leagues that haven’t seen disruption akin to this since WWII?

Hosting the World Cup in a nation with widely different cultural beliefs and morals to the majority of the fans that will be visiting is sure to cause much aggravation and raise tensions. Alcohol sales are extremely limited and it is an offence to drink in public places, drastically effecting fans experiences. There are also issues with the expected behaviour of female fans. Cultural differences in what is considered as ‘appropriate’ female dress has already provoked concern. Homosexuality in Qatar is illegal and may lead to criminal sanctions. This has led many to members of the LGBT claiming that “FIFA is colluding with homophobic discrimination”.

As can be seen, the topic is complex with many factors contributing. From a consequentialism viewpoint it could be said that the Qatar World Cup should not go ahead due to the severe loss of life and human rights issues which have stemmed from it. The consequence of letting a decision swayed by bribery and corruption are also severe.

Conversely, an intuitive standpoint may suggest that the tournament will only help an already growing nation. Hosting what will no doubt be an impressive event will help enhance the nation’s reputation for high standard living.

16: Monika Taneska, Connor Pilling, Benjamin Norman, Edward Marston

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Should the FIFA 2022 World Cup be held in Qatar?

  1. An insightful article and whilst I agree that the innovation in many fields this project could bring would be beneficial throughout the world, I believe that the Qatar World Cup should not go ahead based on the controversy aforementioned in the article. That being said, if the tournament were to go ahead, I would certainly still be watching it.

    Like

  2. Well written. My concern would be: what would the stadium be used for going forward?
    Qatar has historically had very little to do with world sport and I can’t believe they’ll find a use for these stadiums. It just seems a waste.

    Like

  3. Good job Mon–I agree with Amnesty International’s response to push for better reforms to Qatar’s labor practices. Amnesty suggests that FIFA should demand the country to publish a true reform plan in the next year, and “should carry out, and publish, its own regular independent inspections” of the country’s labor practices.

    Like

  4. Good article. FIFA is being ambitious bringing the World Cup to places it has never been before, this I quite like. There could be some interesting outcomes. However it seems that bribery played a larger role in this decision than ambition for diversity.

    Like

  5. Very nice article. While I agree with that hosting this tournament would be beneficial for the countries infrastructure and tourism, the before mentioned human rights concerns should still be considered. In this day and age firms are expected to act ethically and I for one do not think that hosting the World Cup in a coutry that is culturally so different from most of the countries participating in the tournament is an ethical decision.

    Like

  6. A well written article! With regards to the human rights issues with employees, I believe that whether or not the World Cup is hosted in Qatar will have little effect. Poor treatment of employees has always been a reoccurring issue in their culture, hosting the World Cup may mean more are effected, however many those individuals may have came from something similar to begin with. My main concerns lie with the fans. They will be spending an extremely large amount of money to be there and yet due to clashes in culture and morals, their experiences will potentially be severely hindered. All in all, football would not be what it is without the support from the fans, devoting so much energy in Qatar could be a complete waste of money and effort, a chance I do not feel they should take.

    Like

  7. I am outraged! It is an absolute tragedy that this situation has arisen through such corruption, and it shakes my faith in football’s upper echelons. It is the responsibility of FIFA to provide adequate safeguards for workers in this situation and the world cup should never have been awarded to a nation that wasn’t ready to construct the necessary stadiums and facilities without endangering human life. These deaths lie on Sepp Blatter’s conscience! The corruption and bribery charges are the least of his worries – he should be charged with manslaughter if the investigations prove his wrongdoing.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s